Sunday, December 31, 2006

Sunday Roundup/Rangers 4, Caps 1

[NHL.com Recap]

The depleted Caps dropped another game to finish the 2006 calendar year portion of the season at 16-16-7 (recaps galore here). But tomorrow is a new day and a new year. Clean slate. Tabula rasa. We all know that this past week has been brutal on the Caps health- and schedule-wise, so the losses are easily explained away, but the standings points foregone are not so easily parted with. Get healthy and get back to playing Caps hockey - there's plenty of time to right the ship and make the playoffs.

I don't want to spend too much time on last night's game, but did want to take a second to discuss the role Donald Brashear has taken on this team. He has become a fan favorite and undoubtedly a favorite of the guys in the locker room as well for his willingness to keep order at times when games might get out of hand (of course, that is supposed to be the referees' job, but their gross incompetence lately makes me question their ability to do so), and to try to provide a momentum-changing spark with his fists. He has five fights in the last five games, including a couple of absolutely punishing KO's.

But where was he last night when the Caps needed him? In the locker room after being excused for sucker-punching Aaron Ward. He'll likely be suspended for the hit, so there will be a couple more games where The Donald's intimidation won't be available to the Caps (and with John Erskine and Matt Bradley also injured, it leaves the team quite short-handed on the pugilism front).

Now, if the Brashear/Ward incident was sparked, as some are speculating, by Ward's use of a racial epithet, the Ranger defenseman is lucky that he didn't get more from Brash. That is, in many ways, even less excusable than most of the cheap shots thrown around the League on a given night. But if Brashear was incited by a little stickwork or run-of-the-mill trash-talking, he failed his team last night, for as soon as he was tossed from the game, Ranger "tough guy" Colton Orr started running around the ice like an idiot, knowing there would be no reprecussions for his actions; not from the referees and not from the Caps' bruiser.

Eventually, Orr cross-checked Alex Ovechkin across the lower jaw (when AO hadn't even been near the puck in ages), prompting flu-ridden Caps blueliner Shaone Morrisonn to jump Orr despite the knowledge that he would (and did) get his ass kicked. For his effort, Morrisonn got an instigator and a game misconduct in addition to his fighting major, while Orr got the fighting major and a charging minor. And since this incident occurred in the last five minutes of the game, guess what? Morrisonn could be suspended and Coach Glen Hanlon may receive the automatic $10,000 fine that goes with it. As Hanlon accurately summed it up, "Ovechkin gets his teeth loosened with a cross check and we get the instigator. I'm still trying to figure that one out."

I would strenuously argue (from precedent) that Morrisonn should not be suspended and that Hanlon should not be fined for Mo sticking up for his teammate in this instance, but the larger point is that it probably doesn't even come to this if Brashear had kept his cool and stayed in the game.

I like The Donald and think he's been a tremendous addition to this Caps team. But last night he didn't do his job and it's no different than a defenseman who blows his coverage or a goalie who lets in a soft goal - everyone on the team has a role and has to play that role to the best of his ability every night. Brash provides protection and a measure of security for the team's skill players. Can you imagine the liberties that other teams might have been taken without him in the lineup? No need to - you saw one last night and will likely get the chance to see more over the next few games.

UPDATE: Here's the video of the Brashear/Brendan Shanahan fight and the subsequent sucker punch. I didn't mention it above, but kudos to Shanny for challenging the big guy (and for having more guts than the rest of the Ranger roster combined):



Daily Awards
  • Hart: Shane Doan (G, 4A, +3)
  • Ross: Shane Doan (5 points)
  • Norris: Mattias Ohlund (2G, +3, 2 SOG, 3 hits... though maybe Brian Rafalski deserves it more)
  • Vezina: Curtis Joseph (40-save shutout win)
  • Richard: Jeremy Roenick (3G)
  • Calder: Marc-Antoine Pouliot (G, +1 in 6-2 loss)
  • Aiken: Evgeni Nabokov (L, 3 goals allowed on 6 shots against in just 15:11 minutes of work)

4 comments:

PeterGower said...

Exactly my thoughts on Brashear which I posted right after the game: http://www.kuklaskorner.com/index.php/forums/viewthread/1018/

One thing I disagree is about the liberties the other teams would have taken if Brash wouldn't be a around. He was not there last year and Ovechkin was less roughed than in two months of this season. When Brash was hired it was all over in the papers, "to protect Ovechkin". Obviously Orr took liberties because Brash was not around, but where was Brash when Gaustad tried to punch Ovie or when Briere speared him? Now I dare to say that if Brash wouldn't try to rough Jagr, Ovie would have less problems with his teeth.

My take on Brash is that he is a bit of a jerk in a sense that gets wild easy and can't control himself.

If Caps would let him go and hire another bodyguard for Ovechkin, I wouldn't regret a sec.

JP said...

Brash barely touched Jagirl, but I agree with the larger point that he seems to be straying a bit from his role and changing it into something else that's more akin to a circus sideshow.

That said, it's interesting to note that he was wearing an "A" last night, so obviously the team is happy with the role he has been playing.

John said...

Does anyone think McPhee will do anything.....the caps are slowly loosing this season - and its a shame.

Caps Nut said...

I just noticed in the replay of that fight, why wasn't Shanahan ejected? His jersey was not strapped down and that is an automatic ejection. The only reason why it didn't come completely off was because the linesmen bailed Shanahan out.

Yet another example of the poor officiating that took place at MSG on Saturday night.